Is fiduciary liability the same as an ERISA fidelity bond?

No, and this is the most common mix-up in the category. The fidelity bond is generally required under ERISA and protects the plan against fraud or dishonesty by people who handle plan funds. Fiduciary liability is insurance that defends and indemnifies fiduciaries against claims that they breached their duties. Most plan sponsors need both.

We outsourced our retirement plan to a provider. Are we off the hook?

Generally no. Selecting and monitoring a service provider is itself a fiduciary act, and the duty to monitor stays with the plan sponsor. Some advisers do accept fiduciary status for defined portions of the work, which is worth confirming in writing, but the sponsor's oversight responsibility does not disappear.

Who at our company is actually exposed to a fiduciary claim?

Anyone with discretionary authority over the plan or its assets, which commonly includes owners, HR leaders, finance leaders and members of an investment committee. Fiduciary status is determined by function rather than by job title, so people are sometimes fiduciaries without realizing it.

Doesn't our D&O policy already cover this?

Usually not. Most D&O forms exclude ERISA-based claims specifically so that the exposure is written on its own policy. Check the exclusion language rather than assuming the management liability program picks it up. Coverage, exclusions and limits vary by carrier and policy form.

How much does fiduciary liability insurance cost?

There is no reliable published average. Fiduciary liability is priced on the benefit and retirement plans you sponsor: their total assets, the number of participants, whether they include a defined benefit plan, an ESOP or company stock, and how well the plan committee documents its process and monitors fees and advisers. The limit and retention you choose and any prior claims also move the price. Coverage, exclusions and limits vary by carrier and policy form.

Fiduciary Liability Insurance in Missouri

Protects those who manage your retirement or benefit plans from personal liability for plan decisions.

Request My Coverage Review Read the guide

Part of our guides to commercial insurance and nonprofit insurance.

Covers the people responsible for your employee benefit plans when their decisions are challenged.

What It Covers

•Claims that plan assets were imprudently invested
•Allegations of excessive plan fees or poor vendor selection
•Errors in administering or interpreting the plan
•Failure to follow the plan's own written terms
•Personal liability of trustees and plan administrators
•Legal defense costs, including regulatory investigations

Example Scenarios

An employee claims the retirement plan's investment options carried excessive fees
A staff member says enrollment paperwork was mishandled and cost them benefits
A regulator questions how plan contributions were deposited

Who Needs It

•Any nonprofit sponsoring a 401(k), 403(b), or pension plan
•Organizations offering health or welfare benefit plans
•Boards that appoint or oversee plan trustees
•Nonprofits whose staff serve as plan administrators

What this coverage typically responds to

Fiduciary Liability: costs this kind of policy typically covers, and losses it typically excludes. Subject to the issued policy.
Cost or loss	Typical treatment
Defense costs for the organization and individual fiduciaries	Typically covered
Settlements and judgments	Typically covered
Regulatory investigation expenses	Typically covered
Costs of correcting certain plan errors, where included	Typically covered
Benefits the plan simply owes a participant	Typically excluded
Deliberate dishonesty or criminal acts	Typically excluded
Claims already pending when the policy began	Typically excluded
Employment disputes unrelated to the plan (that's EPLI)	Typically excluded
Contributions the organization failed to fund	Typically excluded

Coverage and exclusions, and the exceptions to them, vary by carrier, policy form and endorsement. The issued policy governs.

Why It Matters

Fiduciary liability is personal. Under federal law the people who oversee a benefit plan can be pursued individually, and D&O policies routinely exclude these claims. If your nonprofit offers a retirement plan, someone on your team already carries this exposure.

Limits commonly written

Commonly $1M per claim

How pricing works

Scales with plan assets and participant count — ask for a quote

Availability, eligibility, limits, exclusions, conditions and coverage terms vary by insurer, policy form, endorsement, jurisdiction and individual risk. This is general information, not insurance, legal or tax advice.

Underwriting and cost considerations

Fiduciary liability insurance protects an organization and the individuals who administer its employee benefit plans against claims alleging a breach of fiduciary duty in the management of those plans.

What underwriters evaluate

Which plans are sponsored: defined contribution, defined benefit, health and welfare, or an ESOP
Total plan assets and participant count for each plan sponsored
Who the named fiduciaries are, whether an investment committee exists, and whether it documents its meetings
The investment lineup, the share classes used, and whether fees are benchmarked on a regular schedule
Use of outside advisers and whether any of them accept fiduciary status in writing
Company stock held in the plan, which is a distinct and heavily litigated exposure
Timeliness of participant contribution remittance, plus any prior correction of late deposits
Prior Department of Labor or IRS examinations, plan corrections, participant complaints and prior claims

What affects the premium

Total plan assets across all sponsored plans, the primary exposure base
Number of plan participants
Presence of a defined benefit plan, an ESOP, or company stock as an investment option
Governance quality, including documented committee process, fee benchmarking and adviser oversight
Limit and retention selected
Prior claims, regulatory inquiries and correction history

Common claim types

Excessive fee and imprudent investment allegations brought by plan participants
Claims alleging failure to monitor investment options, advisers or service providers
Improper denial of benefits and errors in plan administration or eligibility determinations
Late, missed or misapplied participant contributions and other operational plan errors
ESOP and company stock claims alleging imprudent valuation or continued investment

Common gaps and misunderstandings

ERISA generally requires a fidelity bond for people who handle plan funds; that bond is not fiduciary liability insurance
The bond addresses fraud and dishonesty, while fiduciary liability addresses breaches of duty, so most sponsors need both
D&O policies commonly exclude ERISA claims, so fiduciary exposure is usually not picked up there
Fiduciary liability is claims-made, so continuity and the retroactive date matter on any carrier change
Individual fiduciaries can be personally liable, and delegating to an adviser does not remove the duty to monitor

Commonly purchased alongside

Directors & Officers (D&O)
Employment Practices Liability
Commercial Crime
Professional Liability (E&O)
Cyber Insurance

Frequently asked questions

Is fiduciary liability the same as an ERISA fidelity bond?: No, and this is the most common mix-up in the category. The fidelity bond is generally required under ERISA and protects the plan against fraud or dishonesty by people who handle plan funds. Fiduciary liability is insurance that defends and indemnifies fiduciaries against claims that they breached their duties. Most plan sponsors need both.
We outsourced our retirement plan to a provider. Are we off the hook?: Generally no. Selecting and monitoring a service provider is itself a fiduciary act, and the duty to monitor stays with the plan sponsor. Some advisers do accept fiduciary status for defined portions of the work, which is worth confirming in writing, but the sponsor's oversight responsibility does not disappear.
Who at our company is actually exposed to a fiduciary claim?: Anyone with discretionary authority over the plan or its assets, which commonly includes owners, HR leaders, finance leaders and members of an investment committee. Fiduciary status is determined by function rather than by job title, so people are sometimes fiduciaries without realizing it.
Doesn't our D&O policy already cover this?: Usually not. Most D&O forms exclude ERISA-based claims specifically so that the exposure is written on its own policy. Check the exclusion language rather than assuming the management liability program picks it up. Coverage, exclusions and limits vary by carrier and policy form.
How much does fiduciary liability insurance cost?: There is no reliable published average. Fiduciary liability is priced on the benefit and retirement plans you sponsor: their total assets, the number of participants, whether they include a defined benefit plan, an ESOP or company stock, and how well the plan committee documents its process and monitors fees and advisers. The limit and retention you choose and any prior claims also move the price. Coverage, exclusions and limits vary by carrier and policy form.

Coverage, exclusions and limits vary by carrier and policy form. Review the applicable policy language, and confirm requirements for your state and operations.

Nonprofit Insurance Checklist: What to Buy and Why
A practical, exposure-first checklist of the coverages a nonprofit should evaluate — plus the five gaps that most often leave organizations paying a claim out of program funds.
Nonprofit D&O Insurance: What Your Board Risks Personally
Nonprofit board members can be named personally. Here is what D&O responds to, where EPLI takes over, and what underwriters ask a board.
Nonprofit Insurance Audit: A Yearly Review Process
A step-by-step annual insurance review for nonprofits — what changed this year, how to read your loss runs, verifying limits against contracts, checking retroactive dates, and preparing for the premium audit.

Request a quote for Fiduciary Liability

Four short steps, about 12 questions. Not sure what coverage you need? Choose “Help me choose.” After you send your request, adding more details is optional.